Mar 142011
 

I currently have 4 store charge cards that all have between 950-1300$ on them apiece. I have not made payments on any of these cards since about September of 2010, due to losing my job. I just recently won an appeal to get a lump sum of back pay from them, and it’s just enough to cover the outstanding debts as they currently stand. Now I am attempting to weigh my options, whether I should pay in full, pay for delete, or settle, or some one way, some another.

To start, last week, I arranged with WFNNB to pay in full two of the cards (~$2000 total), both still being held through them as the OC. I wasn’t really aware of any other option so I gave them my bank account info and set it up that way, as they were threatening legal action if I didn’t do it on that day (I realize this was probably just pressure tactics but I was scared and had intended on paying anyway so I just went with it). The payment will not post until the end of the month, and I was told I could call and cancel it if I was unable to make it. Now I am reading about “pay for delete” and things like that and am wondering if I should just consider that ship sailed (as I’ve basically admitted I have the money), or if I should be calling, cancelling that payment, and asking about PFD. Is PFD going to cost me substantially more? If so, I can only do it for some of the cards– Literally my whole backpay amount is taken up by these cards, since they include late fees.

The other two accounts (Citi and HSBC) I have not yet made arrangements with. They have both offered me settlements which I did not respond to as I did not have the money at the time. I don’t know how to find out whether the debt is still held by the OC or a CA at this point– Looking at my yearly credit report, Citi is listed as charged off but still shows a recent balance, HSBC is just listed as “closed” but also has a recent balance, however the settlement offers I recieve from them are not coming from HSBC, but “firstsource advantage”, so I don’t understand who owns it anymore.

So basically, I am trying to consider the best option for me, both short and long term. Up until the last 8 months, I have always been on time with my payments. I don’t know if my best options are to just pay it off in full and move on, or if I should even be considering settlements, or PFD (some of these accounts are barely 2 years old, some since 2004). I have other accounts in both good and bad standing, but it’s just these four I can’t keep up with and am ready to get away from. Thanks in advance for any advice that you can offer.

 

I was contacted this morning about a debt owed of 3k. They were willing to settle for $1200. Normally I would have jumped on this settlement, but my readings on the boards have taught me to negotiate!

 

I told her that my counter offer was to either:

 

1 – accept the settlement and set up a payment plan to have this reported as settled in full ( I don’t want to take this option)

2 – accept the settlement and pay it all in full to have this deleted or reported as paid in full

 

She said she’s never done this before, but would check with her manager and call me back! I will keep you updated.

Any other ideas on counter offers???

 

Dear Forum Members,

 

I have been writing a settlement offer letter to a collection agency once a month for the past 4 months, and they have not answered any of these letters.  I have proof of their receiving them, and I am able to see who signed for them.  For this reason I obviously know they are just ignoring my letters.

 

I was thinking of writing a letter to them basically saying the following:

 

“I see you have received my settlement letters on (date), and I would like to thank you for not rejecting my offer.  It is nice to see a company working with a client in such a bad economic environment.  I just wanted to let you know that I have the amount of money listed in my settlement letter that you did not reject waiting to be sent to you for settlement on this account.  As the settlement letter stated, I just need a letter sent to me on your company letterhead stating the offer that you received from me. Thank you again for not rejecting the offer.’

 

I know this letter is choppy, but it is a really rough draft which I hope to get your thoughts on.  My hope is to get a response from them, or at least have ammunition showing a court (if they ever sue me) that I have reached out numerous times without a response from them to work out the debt.

 

Thank you.

 

I’ve really been trying to educate myself as I begin taking steps to repair my credit, but I keep coming to the same basic dilemma. I can see why it would make sense to wait out the SOL before contacting CAs and then negotiate for PFD, if you choose to settle at all, but the risk of being sued scares me to death. I’m reading these horror stories of people having funds taken out of their bank accounts, having everything but a little over $200/wk garnished, etc., and that would be even more devastating than the settlement offers I can’t afford.  

As best I can figure, the SOL will run on all of my debts in approximately 210 days, which doesn’t sound like that long, but when you’re looking over your shoulder waiting for a CA to come after you and destroy your life, it feels like an eternity.

Sometimes when I get advice here — which I appreciate very much — people seem so confident in suggesting I do nothing at this point, and I keep wondering why no one seems half as worried about being sued as I am. I’ll admit, it’s my nature to worry, probably excessively, but am I wrong here?

I’ve only settled a few very small accounts so far, mostly $50-100 medical debts and things of that nature, and one CA (and all but one refused to delete), and part of me wonders if there’s any point in trying to make the sacrifices to settle these accounts at all or at least for now.

Any way to measure your risk of being sued? I have some very large accounts weighing heavily on my mind (10-18k w/ the crazy interest and penalties) and keeping me up at night.

As always, any advice is appreciate. Thanks for your time.