I just entered into a non profit accredited debt management/credit counseling program and they took all my credit cards,got the interest rates lowered and wrapped up into one payment a month, at which they will be paid off in 5 years. This obviously seems like the best thing, however, it is a hefty payment every month and my husband and I work on commission so there is no guarantee that we will be able to continue this for 5 years–only hope to…
Â
Upon entering into the program, all but two c/c were current. However, the two that weren’t current were 6 months behind and about to charge off so the credit card company recently offered me a debt settlement of .30 on the dollar. This is tempting since I would save about $19,000. This would also make my debt management payment for the remainder cards a lot easier to handle for the next five years.
Â
Does anyone know the ramifications of a debt settlement? I am getting mixed opinions. Some say I should definitely take the settlement offer since my credit has already taken the biggest hit–(being six months behind) and that my credit would actually improve a little since the debt to income ratio would improve.  They are looking at it  as…  I am going to be on debt management program for the other cards for five years and that will show on credit as a third party helping, which is like a soft bankruptcy and creditors look at it as you are in trouble! They said credit will not drastically improve till I complete the program and cards are paid off in full anyway.They said by then, the settlement won’t effect me.
Â
Others say, the settlement will effect me for 7-10 years and that creditors won’t want to lend me money for this time period since I settled and didn’t pay in full. I know using a debt settlement company is a BIG no no since they charge you, and keep your money in a separate acct for months or even years till your creditors get paid. However, this would be a settlement with the bank and be paid all within 3 months. I do have to make up my mind very soon as the offer will be off the table since I am starting to make payments with debt managementÂ
Â
I also am aware that I would have to pay taxes on the money I saved so I will be consulting my accountant about this soon. Depending on how that will affect me, that may make my decision…
Â
I just want to know if I choose the settlement over the debt management for the two late cards vs.. Keeping all the cards on debt management for 5 years how that will compare and effect me in the end. Any advise would be great!